Salaried Employee Should Select Which Tax Scheme : Old Or New Tax Regime

This blog will contain comprehensive details of Indian tax regimes for ITR-1 and also have a calculator which will work well for AY23-24 and AY24-25.

Jun 27, 2023 - 19:15
Aug 3, 2023 - 21:55
 0  45
Salaried Employee Should Select Which Tax Scheme : Old Or  New Tax Regime
PC- pexels.com

Table of Contents: 

            1. New Tax Regime
            2. Old Tax Regime
            3. Tax Calculation Example
            4. Conclusion
            5Excel Calculator for Old and New Tax Regimes


New Tax Regime

There was a major change in the union Budget 2020 and tax slabs were altered, and the tax payment with this new tax slab is called as New Tax Regime. This tax regime offers good tax savings even without having long-term savings like FD/PPF etc. The major drawback of this regime is that several exemptions just as HRA, LTC, 80C, and 80D can not be claimed. This tax scheme is not popular because of  such reasons although the union government had announces some major changes in it-

  • Higher Tax Rebate Limit: The tax rebate limit has been increased up to 7 lakhs irrespective of the old tax regime where the tax rebate limit was only 5 lakhs. This shows that employees or individual taxpayers have to pay less tax subject to exemption and total income. 
  • Minimum Income Tax Limit: The tax exemption limit has been increased up to 3 lakhs. 
  • Tax Slabs: The tax slabs in the new tax regime are as follows- 

Income Slab

(In INR)

New Tax Regime

(Until 31-03-23)

New Tax Regime

( From 01 April 2023)

0 -2,50,000

NIL

NIL

2,50,000-3,00,000

5%

NIL

3,00,000-5,00,000

5%

5%

5,00,000-6,00,000

10%

5%

6,00,000-7,50,000

10%

10%

7,50,000-9,00,000

15%

10%

9,00,000-10,00,000

15%

15%

10,00,000-12,00,000

20%

15%

12,00,000-12,50,000

20%

20%

12,50,000 -15,00,000

25%

20%

> 15,00,000

30%

30%

      


Old Tax Regime

The old tax slab was implemented prior to the introduction of the new tax scheme in the budget 2020. The old tax slab was quite popular and the adopter of this tax slab were enjoys almost 70 exemptions and deductions including HRA and LTC. The most popular deduction under this regime was 80C which permits the exemption of up to 1.5 lakhs from taxable income. The tax slabs are:

Net Taxable Income Old Tax Regime Slab Rates FY 2022-23
Up to Rs 2.5 lakh Exempt
Rs 2,50,001 to Rs 5 lakh 5%
Rs 5,00,001 to Rs 7.5 lakh 20%
Rs 7,50,001 to Rs 10 lakh
Rs 10,00,001 to Rs 12.5 lakh 30%
Rs 12,50,001 to Rs 15 lakh
Over Rs. 15 lakh


Tax Calculation Examples

Now we compute taxes in certain tax regimes and try to find out which one is better under certain given assumptions:

  • Total deductions are ₹1.5 lakhs or less: New regime will be beneficial, 
  • Assumptions in old tax computation- 1.5 L Deductions and 50k Standard Deductions.
  • New Tax regime Deduction before budget 23- No deduction, Tax rebate up to 5L
  • New Tax regime Deduction After budget 23- 50k Standard Deduction, Tax rebate up to 7L
Gross Income

Old Tax Regime

New Tax Regimes For AY 23-24 For AY 23-24
Pre-Budget 23 Post Budget 23
      Differences Preference Differences Preference
500000 0 0 0 0 Anyone 0 Anyone
600000 0 22500 0 -22500 New   0 Anyone
700000 0 32500 0 -32500 Old 0 Anyone
800000 32500 45000 30000 -12500 Old 2500 New
900000 52500 60000 40000 -7500 Old 12500 New
1000000 72500 75000 52500 -2500 Old 20000 New
1100000 92500 95000 67500 -2500 Old 25000 New
1200000 112500 11500 82500 101000 New   30000 New
1300000 142500 137500 10000 5000 New   132500 New
1400000 172500 162500 120000 10000 New   52500 New
1500000 202500 187500 140000 15000 New   62500 New
1700000 262500 247500 195000 15000 New   67500 New
2000000 352500 337500 285000 15000 New   67500 New
2500000 502500 487500 435000 15000 New   67500 New
3000000 652500 637500 585000 15000 New   67500 New

  • Total deductions are more than ₹3.75 lakhs: Old regime will be beneficial
  • Assumptions in old tax computation- 80C- 1.5L, 80CCD(1)- 50k, 80D- 25k,  Deductions and 50k, Standard Deductions, loan interest- 1.5L.
  • New Tax regime Deduction before budget 23- No deduction, Tax rebate up to 5L
  • New Tax regime Deduction After budget 23- 50k Standard Deduction, Tax rebate up to 7L

Gross Income

(In INR)

Old Tax Regime New Tax Regimes For AY 23-24 For AY 23-24
Pre-Budget 23 Post Budget 23
 
 
 
Differences Preference Differences Preference
500000 0 0 0 0 Anyone 0 Anyone
600000 0 22500 0 -22500 Anyone 0 Anyone
700000 0 32500 0 -32500 Anyone 0 Anyone
800000 0 45000 30000 -45000 New -30000 Old
900000 0 60000 40000 -60000 New -40000 Old
1000000 27500 75000 52500 -47500 New -25000 Old
1100000 47500 95000 67500 -47500 New -20000 Old
1200000 67500 115000 82500 -47500 New -15000 Old
1300000 87500 137500 100000 -50000 New -12500 Old
1400000 107500 162500 120000 -55000 New -12500 Old
1500000 135000 187500 140000 -52500 New -5000 Old
1700000 195000 247500 195000 -52500 New 0 Anyone
2000000 285000 337500 285000 -52500 New 0 Anyone
2500000 435000 487500 435000 -52500 New 0 Anyone
3000000 585000 637500 585000 -52500 New 0 Anyone


  • When total deductions are between ₹1.5lakhs to ₹3.75 lakhs: will depend on your income level
  • Assumptions in old tax computation- 80C- 1.5L, 80CCD(1)- 0k, 80D- 25k,  Deductions and 50k, Standard Deductions, loan interest- 1.0L.
  • New Tax regime Deduction before budget 23- No deduction, Tax rebate up to 5L
  • New Tax regime Deduction After budget 23- 50k Standard Deduction, Tax rebate up to 7L
Gross Income Old Tax Regime New Tax Regimes For AY 23-24 For AY 23-24
Pre-Budget 23 Post Budget 23
  Differences Preference Differences Preference
500000 0 0 0 0 Anyone 0 Anyone
600000 0 22500 0 -22500 Anyone 0 Anyone
700000 0 32500 0 -32500 Anyone 0 Anyone
800000 0 45000 30000 -45000 New -30000 Old
900000 27500 60000 40000 -32500 New -12500 Old
1000000 47500 75000 52500 -27500 New -5000 Old
1100000 67500 95000 67500 -27500 New 0 Anyone
1200000 87500 115000 82500 -27500 New 5000 New
1300000 107500 137500 100000 -30000 New 7500 New
1400000 135000 162500 120000 -27500 New 15000 New
1500000 165000 187500 140000 -22500 New 25000 New
1700000 225000 247500 195000 -22500 New 30000 New
2000000 315000 337500 285000 -22500 New 30000 New
2500000 465000 487500 435000 -22500 New 30000 New
3000000 615000 637500 585000 -22500 New 30000 New


Conclusions

In order to know the suitable tax regime follow the given steps:

  • Download the Excel attached to the blog.
  • Fill in the input cells marked in yellow color. 
  • Once the data input is over, the Excel on the right side will show the required output "SAYING WHICH TAX REGIME NEEDS TO BE SELECTED IN ORDER TO GET MAXIMUM POSSIBLE SAVING".
  • Enjoy the ITR filing........

Files

What's Your Reaction?

like

dislike

love

funny

angry

sad

wow